Mabel Arilla Payne Sanders: A Strong Woman Whose Courage Has Been Passed Down in Our Family (In honor of Women’s History Month) #52Ancestors

Mabel Arilla Payne

By Marilyn Sears Lindsey

March 5, 2018 – Week 10

One of the strongest women I know is my maternal grandmother, Mabel Arilla Payne.  When she was young in the early 20th century, she told her mother that she wanted to become a nurse.  Her mother replied: Become a mother and you’ll be an excellent nurse.  So she followed in the footsteps of mothers everywhere and became the extraordinary matriarch of our family.

11.25.1950 Mabel & Paul's Wedding
Mabel and her 5 daughters on November 25, 1950 at Mabel & Paul’s Wedding; Back row: Jean, Phoebe, Flo; Front row: Claire, Mabel Arilla and Mabel Eunice.


Mabel Sanders, Mabel Adams, Claire Sears, Phoebe Glaze and Flo Hightower and pos
Mabel Arilla, great-grandson and 4 of her 5 daughters – Mabel Eunice, Claire, Phoebe and Florence circa 1995
1953 Lee, Bob & Jim Life and Times Disc 3 Contents
Leland, Bob and Jim circa 1953

All 3 of Mabel’s sons served in the military – Lee joined the US Navy in 1944; Jim was in the US Army in 1948 in the Korean War; and Bob joined the US Navy.

Mabel Arilla Payne lived from 1904 – 2005.  The extraordinary women mentioned here were her contemporaries.

MABEL’S CONTEMPORARY: Lillian Gilbreth (1878-1972) was a mother and Industrial Engineer who had 12 children.

1904 at 1 day old

Elizabeth (1901-1991) was 3 years old when her sister Mabel was born.  Mabel was one of the strongest women I know because she only weighed one pound when she was born prematurely.  Her parents had her sleep on a pillow in an open dresser drawer so they could keep an eye on her.

Mabel & Lizzie
Mabel & Lizzie circa 1905

Then her father died in a sawmill accident when she was only 1 month old.  She had to be strong to survive.  Mabel was the 4th oldest of 8 kids (her 2 older brothers Alfred and Albert died before they were 1 year old).  When Mabel was 3, her brother Arthur (1907-1962) was born and when she was 4 her brother Austin (1908-1909) was born but only lived one year.  She had one more sister Ethel (1917-2005) and one more brother James (1921-1995).  Five of the 8 siblings lived to adulthood.

Circa 1915 at 11 years old

Mabel was an animal lover and enjoyed having dogs…just like Claire’s 3 kids – Ray, Marilyn and Pam and all 7 of Claire’s granddaughters.

1915 Lizzie, George Nelson Trask, Lizzie, Arthur and Mabel
Minnie Greene, Dog, George Nelson Trask, Lizzie Payne, Arthur Ballou and Mabel Payne (age 11) Circa 1915
Charlie O'Connell, who, Mabel Payne, Dennis O'Connell and Alice Delmonico
Charlie O’Connell, Baby, Mabel, Dennis O’Connell and Alice Delmonico & Dog c 1922

MABEL’S CONTEMPORARY: Dixy Lee Ray (1914-1994) who was a zoologist and the first female governor of Washington State.

Mabel Arilla Payne was not only strong; she was lucky.  She survived a car crash, a broken leg and some surgeries.  She could spot a four-leaf clover the minute she walked out the door.  She gave so many away to family and friends.  Her grands and great-grands remember her for that.

5.5.2018 Jill's Bowlful of Four-Leaf Clovers
Jill collected a bowlful of four-leaf clovers while I was writing this tribute to Mabel Arilla 5.5.2018

1916 at 12 years old

She was christened on August 20, 1916 at the First Baptist Church in Mendon, Massachusetts and supported the Salesian Missions.

Mabel Aurilla Payne Baptism Certificate.jpg

03.17.1951 62 C&L 62 Claire & Les Wedding
She also attended the Upton Methodist Church where Claire and Les were married on March 17, 1951.
Alissa at Genesis Internship
Alissa Marie Lindsey at a Genesis Fundraiser on November 10, 2017

Alissa followed in Mabel‘s footsteps and has made the church her passion.  She will graduate from Perkins School of Theology with a Master of Arts in Ministry in May 2018.

MABEL’S CONTEMPORARY: Mary Slessor (1848-1915) was similar to Mabel in 2 ways.  Mary was a mill girl in Scotland where she spent her leisure time volunteering to teach the children at church.

1918 at 14 years old

She was an artist as she wove cloth in the 1920s at a cotton mill, did needlework – mostly crochet- in her spare time and made afghans for as many children and grandchildren as asked for one.  Her entire apartment was decorated with crocheted toaster covers, pillows, afghans, slippers and vests. She even made her own coat.

Mabel Sanders
Mabel Sanders Day at the Sylmar Branch of the LA Public Library 12.11.1974;
Afghan Donation 2003

Every week at the mill Mabel had to give her wages to her stepfather Javan Everett Ballou, a florist.  After that she learned how to be a financier and business manager as she raised her children with Roy’s paycheck from his brother‘s auto shop and her wages from the hat shop.

Alice Lynn Sanders, Katie Sears, Valorie Sears Mantle, Pam Sears Cooper and Marilyn Sears Lindsey love to draw, design and do needlework.  Pam, Angelica Leal Johnson, Ray Sears and Neil Adams followed in her financier footsteps.

Mabel’s Contemporaries: Aline Bernstein (1881-1955) Costume designer

Muriel Siebert (1928-2013) was the first woman to own a seat on the New York Stock Exchange.  During World War 2 she said: American business will find that women executives can be a strong competitive weapon against Japan and Germany and other countries that still limit their executive talent pool to the male 50 percent of their population.

1925 at 20 years old

Mabel married Clarence Leroy Sanders on the 20th of October 1925.  She said they didn’t have a wedding cake.  They had an apple pie.

JB Mabel and Clarence
Mabel married Clarence Leroy (Roy) Sanders.


JB Mabel Payne Marriage Cert.jpg

JB Mabel and Roy's Wedding Certificate.jpg

JB Mabel & Roy in Wagon
Two kids, Mabel and Roy circa 1926

1926 at 22 years old

Mabel had 8 children in 15 years and breastfed all of them.

Sanders Minus Bob
L to R: Jim,  Phoebe, Claire, Mabel, Jean, Flo and Lee Circa 1940
Bob, Dog & Jean
Bob, puppy and Jean Circa 1948


Babies were her passion.  She even wrote a poem about them.

Starring the Baby

By  Mabel Arilla Payne (Spitfire)

Baby eyes and baby face

They are such a treasure

Just to look and watch them smile

Gives me such a pleasure

Dimpled cheeks and dimpled hands

And the sweetest little voice

Of all the nice things in this world

I know I’ve got my choice.

Little fingers softly twine,

As you rock them to and fro

Their little eyes almost speak

And say, “I love you so,”

At night when they go to sleep

All tucked in nice and warm

They know that you will guard them

From all danger and all harm.

1930 at 26 years old

My Grandpa Roy was a cracker jack mechanic before World War I and a Private in the US Army Ambulance Company 304 301 Sanitary Train Unit where he was an ambulance driver in France.

JB Private Clarence Leroy Roy Sanders
Private Roy Sanders circa 1917

He suffered from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), what used to be called Shell Shock.  He was treated for this disorder in the Veteran’s Administration Hospital for over 2 decades and he passed away there at the age of 71.

One of the early signs of this disorder was probably when he took the family for a Sunday drive around 1930 and kept right on driving from Massachusetts to Upper Jay, New York.  They lived there near his family for 3 years during “The Potato Years” which was what Mabel called them.  They ate only potatoes.

Lee, Minnie and Claire
Lee, Minnie and Claire   circa 1928


Minnie Levinia Greene Payne, died when she was only 44 years old from myocarditis.  Minnie was Mabel’s mother.  Mabel was only 26 and had to learn how to be a mother on her own; without the help of her own mother.

1926 Lee and Mabel
Lee and Mabel circa 1926


MABEL’S CONTEMPORARIES: The Founders of La Leche League (LLL) – a breastfeeding support group- remind me of Mabel.  Marian Tompson, born in 1929 and Mary Ann Kerwin, born in 1931 are two of the Founders of LLL.  Claire, Pam and I had the pleasure of meeting them in 2015 on an LLL Alumnae Trip to Charleston, SC.  What inspirations they are!

11.07.2015 DAY 4 Founders on 1st LLL Alum Trip to Charleston
Marilyn, Marian Tompson, Claire, Mary Ann Kerwin , Pam 11.7.2015


Mabel did become like a nurse as she raised her children.  She had 1 sheet of paper with all their names and the dates they contracted childhood diseases like measles, mumps, chicken pox and diptheria.

Five of her seven great granddaughters on Claire’s side have careers in the medical field.  I wonder if this is where they get the inspiration from.

MABEL’S CONTEMPORARY: Mabel Keaton Staupers (1890-1989) of Barbados, West Indies who was a nurse during World War II.

DEF V1P01 07.26.1963 Leslie R. Sears, Jr. receives the Army Commendation Medal
Les received the Army Commendation Medal July 1963

Luckily Ray, Marilyn and Pam had lifelong examples from Claire and Les on how to be parents; we didn’t have to do it by ourselves.

Neither did Angelica, Valorie or Hannah; they had their parents examples too.

Day 9 Angel's Camera
Ryan, Angelica and Marilyn February 27, 2012


12.05.2017 Val, Aria, Ray and Vickie Arrive on Florida Family Reunion.jpg
Valorie, Aria, Ray and Vickie in Treasure Island FL Dec 2017
uncrop 04.07.2018 Pam, Hannah & Cooper
Pam, Cooper and Hannah March 2018

1933 at 29 years old

Mabel was an author/poet just like Ayn Rand (b. Russia) 1905- 1982 and even had one of her poems printed in the Boston Globe in 1933…


By Mabel Arilla Payne Sanders 

They say we are tied

We never can go

To a ball or a dance

Or a good movie show.


We have few pleasures

Much work and worry.

Every day it’s just

Hustle and hurry.


There’s always a little

Shoe to tie

Another to love

So they won’t cry.


The baby needs to

Be picked up

One just broke

Another cup.


That’s what we mothers

Get every day

Mixed in with work

It is our play.


But I wouldn’t

Change a thing,

Would you?

Instead of a show

I’d rather tie a wee shoe.

Her daughter Claire and her great granddaughter, Alissa Marie Lindsey, are following in her footsteps; they are writers too.

 Mabel didn’t graduate from high school herself but she made sure her 8 children did and they all made their way in the world using their education.

Her daughter Jean and her granddaughter Marilyn are teachers.

MABEL’S CONTEMPORARY: Grace Abbott (1878-1939) was a teacher who ensured that child labor was limited in contracts with the US government.

1942 at 46 years old

She was a volunteer – a philanthropist as president of the Mission Belles of the World War 2 Women’s Auxiliary #2285 for 2 years.

Mabel and the Mission Belles WWII
Mabel and the Mission Belles circa 1942 during World War 2

Alissa is a philantropist like her great grandmother as she is interning at a women’s shelter in Dallas and wants to make that her career – social justice.

MABEL’S CONTEMPORARY:  Mabel may have gotten philanthropic ideas from Olave Baden-Powell from England who started the Girl Guides there as her role model.

1976 at 72 years old

Mabel was a traveler and an adventurer. When she got bored with one house, she re-positioned the staircase while the children were in school for the day.  She moved almost 30 times in her life and vacationed in Hawaii when she was 72 years old.  She was a romantic – her favorite movie was Dr. Zhivago (1965) with Omar Sharif and Julie Christie. I wonder if she had notions of even more international traveling than just Hawaii.

Mabel Sanders visits Hawaii from  Life and Times Disc 3 Contents.jpg
Mabel in Hawaii 1976
Mabel and Bird_0001.jpg
               Mabel 1979

She traveled from New York to Florida in a pickup truck to be nearby on my wedding day in 1993 when she was 89 years old. We felt so honored.

Life and Times Disc 3 Contents.jpg

All 7 great granddaughters in Claire’s line love to travel.

Mabel’s Contemporary: Anne Morrow Lindbergh (1906-1993) who surveyed the Orient by way of the Arctic Circle and wrote Gift from the Sea, her most enduring work.

2003 at 99 years old

Mabel A. Sanders' 99th Bday.jpg

2005 at 100 years old

She was a historian when she told the stories of her 7 siblings, her 8 children, her 21 grandchildren, 36 great-grandchildren, 22 great-great grandchildren and 1 great-great-great granddaughter (for a GRAND total of 88 descendants).

Many of her descendants have been named for Mabel and Roy’s ancestors, for example, her daughter Claire was named after Jasper Sanders and Phoebe Ann Kinney’s daughter Elizabeth Claire (1886-1941) and Mabel’s daughter Florence was named after Jasper and Phoebe’s daughter Florence Ellen (1889-1976).  Mabel’s daughter Phoebe Anne was named after Henry Kinney and Vienna Horton’s daughter Phoebe Ann (1855-1927).

Mabel Sanders is 100_0001.jpg

Ray at Shawnee during Pam & Gram's Visit for Alissa's OU Graduation.jpg
Marilyn, Ray and Pam in Shawnee OK on 5.9.2016

Her 3 grandchildren on Claire’s side are Family Historians doing genealogy and making family photo albums.

Mabel’s Contemporary: Mary Ritter Beard (1876-1958) who was a historian and whose major work was Women as a Force in History.

Mabel meets Violet Morris – her most recent great-grandchild circa March 4, 2005

Gramma & Violet Order 4xd & 3x5 (Last known picture of Gramma)

With a role model like Mabel, we were all bound to succeed.   But that’s another story…



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s